Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez sued by people she blocked on Twitter
In the lawsuits, both men allege that they were blocked by Rep. Ocasio-Cortez on Twitter after criticizing her on the platform. “Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez blocked me from viewing and engaging with her official Twitter profile after I responded to one of her political posts,” wrote Saladino under the lawsuit’s statement of claim. Hikind claims that the New York congresswoman blocked him after he was critical of her on Twitter, and mentions other critics that she’s also blocked, such as conservative journalist Ryan Saavedra.
Over the past year, federal courts have considered whether President Donald Trump — and by extension, all public officials — have a right to block critics on a public forum like Twitter. Overwhelmingly, the consensus of the courts has been that access to a politician on social media is, in fact, a constitutional right. Back in January, the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that a public official’s Facebook page is a public forum, so public officials cannot block people for their opinions. This week’s ruling from the US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit concurred with that ruling.
Even before the Trump ruling, courts were siding with the public on the banning rights of elected officials. Back in 2018, the ACLU and the Maryland Board of Public Works reached a settlement in a social media banning lawsuit against Maryland Governor Larry Hogan. Hogan was forced to create a new social media policy for his Facebook page, as well as create an appeals process for constituents who feel that they were wrongfully blocked or that their comments were improperly deleted. The ACLU has also been sending letters to politicians around the country, warning them to unblock people on social media. “The fact that a public official disagrees with you on an issue doesn’t mean she can silence you. Indeed, it means the opposite — and that holds true whether you’re speaking out in a public park, at a town hall meeting, or on a Facebook page,” wrote ACLU staff attorney Vera Eidelman in a blog post earlier this year.
The office of Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez hasn’t responded to a request for comment, so it’s unclear how they will respond to the lawsuits — but both Saladino and Hinkind state in their lawsuits that they seek to be unblocked by Ocasio-Cortez.